Now a rather odd comparison of two specific butter substitutes.... You'll see why I call it odd.
Flora Buttery vs ALDI Beautifully Buttery
Both made with buttermilk, and superficially similar.
Flora £2.15 (-2.50) for 450g. Sneaky bu66ers cut it from 500g
Beautifully Buttery 99p
Looked like a no brainer. You get 10% more and it's less than half the price. What's the catch?
Ingredients - Flora:-
Plant Oils (Rapeseed, Palm¹, Sunflower 1%, Linseed), Water, 𝐁𝐮𝐭𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐦𝐢𝐥𝐤 10%, Salt 1.35%, Plant Based Emulsifier (Lecithin), Natural Flavourings, Vitamin A, ¹Flora buys 100% sustainable Palm Oil
Ingredients - Beautifully Buttery:-
Water, Vegetable Oils In Varying Proportions (Rapeseed, Palm And Palm Kernel Oil, Sunflower), Reconstituted 𝐁𝐮𝐭𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐦𝐢𝐥𝐤 (5%), Modified Maize Starch, Salt (1,5%), Emulsifiers: Mono- And Diglycerides Of Fatty Acids, Lecithins; Preservative: Potassium Sorbate; Acid: Lactic Acid; Colours: Annatto Bixin, Curcumin; Flavouring.
What the heck! The Aldi product's main ingredient is WATER. No doubt the latter emulsifiers were clever chemistry to make the water hide.
And it shows up in the calories per 10g
Flora: 67kCal
B. Buttery: 41kCal
There's 50% more calories in the Flora !!!
So, what's it like on toast?
Flora spread like Flora... But the B.Buttery melted VERY quickly as it was spread. I found myself serving up nearly twice as many knife-fulls per round of toast !!!
Taste test: Almost indistinguishable, but then the taste panel all have various levels of cold infection.
Is it a good substitute?
The jury's still out. Being half the price is the plus, but will that be negated by using twice as much?
I'll update this post when/if we finish the tub.
Other substitute buttery products suggestions?
Aldi's 'Meadow Flower' at £1.29 looks a better ingredient match to Flora.
Footnote. Flora is £2.50/450g in ASDA but 69p/250g in Farmfoods. That Farmfoods deal is a steal if your branch has stock.